Showing posts with label pirates. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pirates. Show all posts

Thursday, April 23, 2009

Terrorists Won't Become Like Pirates

I was going to make this a comment to Ed's last post. But as I was writing it, it seemed like there was enough content to make a new post out of it. We'll see, won't we?

Terrorists won't become like pirates. They don't fit into the established Western tradition of rebel worship. This tradition goes back a long ways; certainly nearly a thousand years. Consider figures like Robin Hood, Jesse James, and Andre Agassi. We love them all! And why not? They kill people in authority, flout current standards of morality, and answer to no one. (Well, maybe that doesn't go for Agassi - I don't recall him murdering anyone. But I could be wrong. In any event, he's still a rebel.)

But bloodlust is not why we love them. Rather, it's that they represent freedom. Emily was right when she noted that most modern depictions of pirates focus on searching for buried treasure, exploration, and just general carousing. There's a part of us that wants to be able to do those things - pick up and leave whenever we want, do as we choose, do things no one has ever done before. Sail off into the sunset; ride a lone horse into the sunset; follow a jungle trail...into the sunset. (Sunsets are the key to freedom, apparently.)

But we can't. We have to raise crops, raise families, and follow most of the rules most of the time. It's called society, and it's worked for thousands of years. When society works, it's a wonderful thing. It lets us eat and live comfortably. And it allows us to do things that the cavemen never could. Science and literature, arts and industry - all the advances of mankind are because we buy into society.

There's little pieces of us that still feel like cavemen, though. And fortunately, those bits of us are largely satisfied by allowing a very few people to live that life outside the law. We secretly root for them, and we celebrate them because they let the rest of us live productive lives. If everyone were an outlaw, nothing would ever get done. But if Jesse James robs a couple dozen banks over the course of a couple decades, we can lean on our desks and say, "Man! Did you hear about that last job the James Gang pulled? Phew! Always staying one step ahead of the law, too. Alright - now what were you saying about the third quarter actuarial adjustments?"

It's a fine line, however, between outlaws and fanatics. We like the idea of a little rebelliousness out there; we don't like fanaticism. Why not? Because fanatics aren't any more free than the rest of us - they're slaves to their ideology, and that's not very romantic. This is why terrorists won't be like pirates. They're both on the fringes of society, but we're scared of the parts of us that are fanatical, whereas we are wistful about the parts of us that want freedom.

How can you tell which side of the line someone falls? I think it can all be boiled down to something I call the plush doll test. If you can imagine a historical figure or archetype as a plush doll, it's a rebel or an outlaw. If you can't, then it's a fanatic. For example: Robin Hood - plush doll. Torquemada - not a plush doll. Pirate - plush doll. Ku Klux Klansman - not a plush doll.

And here's where I disagree with Amy. I don't think that Nazis are like pirates, either. We don't celebrate Nazis as a general rule. We tend either to demonize or ridicule them. And we do this, again, because we're afraid of the dark corners of humanity that they represent. They fail the plush doll test.

Like I said, it can be a fine line. But I'm convinced that terrorists will never be like pirates.

Saturday, April 18, 2009

Pirates Are Fun and Hilarious! Arr!

Arrr! I'm a pirate, matey! Ha ha ha ... I'm not really a pirate. But me and my Internet buddies just think pirates are hilarious and fun! I've got a pirate costume and everything and I always get big into "Talk Like a Pirate Day" (a real day)!  I've got a load of great pirate jokes too ... hey, where did the pirate go for lunch? Arrrby's! Ha ha ha ...

Hold on a second, I'm just hearing something on the news ... apparently some actual pirates terrorized an American freighter and held its captain at gunpoint? Arrr ... ar ... hmmm. Somehow now pirates are now less fun and hilarious. (And I should also stop putting my news on a one-week time delay. I don't know why I do that.)

I should explain here. I noticed a while ago that pirates were becoming a hi-LAR-ious cultural touchstone, particularly among Internet dorks. Maybe it was the fault of "Pirates of the Caribbean" -- I think it actually goes back to the Sea Captain character on the Simpsons -- but dorks have been finding endless hilarity in pirates for a while. (Among Internet dorks, the latest hilarious cultural touchstone is bacon. No joke. Man, I should really write a whole history and taxonomy of American nerd culture in the 21st century. Some people probably think it's still big glasses and pocket protectors, but it's blossomed into a massive, varied cultural tapestry, complete with a wide range of subcultures.) 

The pirate fascination always struck me as 1) annoying -- pirate voices are extremely easy to do and extremely lame (imagine your boss coming up to you and going "Arr! Avast ye swabs for a team meeting at 10!" and you'll understand what I'm saying) and 2) a little odd, considering that pirates were the terrorists of their day. They boarded ships, killed people, took their stuff -- they were, by definition, horrible people. 

The "pirates are fun" thing even stretches into kids' programming -- ever seen a show called "The Wiggles"? It's absolutely dreadful, so don't. It's a bunch of hammy Australian men wearing brightly colored shirts and singing terrible songs with a painful degree of enthusiasm. Kids love it, of course -- for kids, there's no such thing as "too enthusiastic." 

Point is, one of the Wiggles plays a funny pirate, complete with an eyepatch and pegleg and whole getup. I would watch it and marvel at how pirates are now considered so harmless and fun that they can be on goofy kids shows, when they were once the nightmare of the world. And I wondered if someday kids' shows will have a fun and harmless terrorist. Some goofy, fun guy with dynamite strapped to his chest telling kids to brush regularly, that kind of thing.

Anyway, thanks to the Somali pirates, the pirate trend has presumably suffered a sudden heart attack and died. I owe them a debt of gratitude for that. Though, I admit, my first reactions to the Somali piracy story were more like:

"What the fuck? Do they know who they're dealing with? Do they not get newspapers? This is the United States of Fucking America you're dealing with, hotshot. We destroyed an entire country just because some guy told us their leader got yellowcake from Niger. And we don't even know what yellowcake is!"

And then when I heard that Navy Seals shot 'em all, my nice, liberal, Amnesty-International self got dropped to the curb and I said:

"Fuck yeah, bitches! U! S! F! A! U! S! F! A!"

And it's sad the people had to die, etc., etc. But c'mon, if there's one time we can satisfy a little bloodlust, it's against pirates. Now we just need to go after the Wiggles. (Post script: One of the Wiggles actually did die recently. So that's not funny. Not that it was anyway.)